On Friday, 11/13, I traveled with my cohort to the Connellsville Canteen to present a sample of the research we have been conducting on behalf of local business owners in Fayette County. Ahead of this presentation, I was actually feeling quite nervous. A normal class project lives and dies in a classroom–classmates and professors are the only people that really see your work and pass judgement on it. This relationship is comfortable, normal, and expected. However, this project, which we were asked to do as part of Pitt’s ongoing partnership with the Fayette County Cultural Trust, is different. Knowing that we were going to be presenting our work to real clients really changed the way I thought and felt about the whole project.
As a senior, I have made peace with the fact that presentations are a common occurrence and can be pretty uncomfortable. The presentation at the Canteen was no exception, though I tried to remind myself of all the uncomfortable presentations that I have made it through without any catastrophic incidents. Even still, I feel as though I bumbled through my sentences and did not present in a way that I was proud of, though I remain hopeful that I got my point across. Looking ahead, I hope to save myself at least a small amount of discomfort by being more prepared for our presentation at the ACRI Conference in DC.
We presented a sampling of the research that will be included in our final research reports, which are scheduled to be delivered to our clients this Thursday. Each client will be receiving a lengthy research report with two main sections. The first section is universal to each client and contains macroeconomic data, income and employment data, and demographic data, as well as analysis of those factors at the national, state, and local levels. Providing data at different levels allows us to provide clients with a picture of the economy at large and how it relates to operating a small business in Fayette County. Details like borrowing costs, local demographics, and industry growth may not be applicable to each business in the current STEPP Forward cohort, but the information is there if they need it.
Recognizing that we are not real business consultants, assembling the reports was as much a learning experience for us as they are a resource for our clients. The process of researching, structuring, and writing the reports as a group was an exercise in collaboration and project management. At the same time, working with our clients and the mentorship we received from faculty along the way have helped us to be able to think more like consultants and to be a resource to our clients. Service learning is best when both parties get something out of the partnership and when the service is well integrated with the classroom content (Delli Carpini and Keeter). Personally, I think that I learned a lot from the experience of working with my client and doing research on her behalf.
My client is Yvonica Melvin, a retired educator who currently operates a notary business with her husband. Through the process of operating their notary business, they started to notice that people had difficulties in certain organizational matters that often accompany notary services. In particular, they noticed their clients needed help in times of major transition; they needed help in care planning for elderly relatives, finding available resources, and handling the logistics and funding of senior care. Those are exactly the services that Yvonica’s new business venture, Better Way Consulting, provides. This is unique, especially considering its integration with Melvin’s Notary. In my research, I did not find any direct competitors that offer this kind of personalized consulting service with the added benefit of integration with a notary service.
My research for Yvonica centered on validating the idea of this unique business venture and researching pricing models to ensure her time is not taken advantage of by clients. It is hard to say, as an outside researcher, whether I think there is enough demand to sustain this business model because the clientele for Better Way Consulting is largely referred through their notary business. Demand for Better Way is reliant on people seeking out notary services who might then be referred to Better Way, or on word of mouth. I made several recommendations in my report, including implementing a monthly retainer fee structure and establishing an online presence, all of which will be delivered to Yvonica later this week.
Looking ahead, I would encourage both Pitt and the Fayette County Cultural Trust to keep thinking creatively about which projects offer the most mutual benefit for students and the community. I think this project was successful in the sense that it was challenging for us. In my opinion, the challenge in this project was the project management aspect. I think we all experienced first-hand how important project management skills are and have gained skills to take with us into whatever comes next.
In the same way that this partnership emphasizes an asset-based approach to economic development, I think that projects should focus on student strengths as well. Being a group of students from diverse majors, many of us had little or no exposure to the world of business consulting before this project. Speaking for myself, I struggled with putting together my report and understanding what is relevant for a small business. Projects that start from what students already do well would help them contribute more meaningfully while still learning along the way.
Delli Carpini, Michael X., and Scott Keeter. “What Should Be Learned through Service Learning?” PS: Political Science and Politics, vol. 33, no. 3, 2000, pp. 635–37, https://doi.org/10.2307/420870.
